Matthew Cerrone

Poll: Has Your Opinion of Willie Changed?
By Matthew Cerrone - May 22, 2008 7:25 am

Yesterday, Willie randolph issued an apology to his team, SNY and the fans, while being interviewed on WFAN, which you can read about here, as well as on SNY in an interview with Kevin Burkhardt, which you can see here.

Having had a chance to watch both interviews, how would you say your opinion of Randolph has changed, since the two interviews?

[Poll=99]

For more on Randolph’s apology, check out NY Sports Day, the New York Post, Newsday, and the Star Ledger.

Lastly, in a fantastic column for the New York Post, Joel Sherman explains why it is wins and losses, not race, or TV coverage or fan perception, that has Randolph in hot water.

RSS feed

33 Comments »

Comment by RPsJacket
2008-05-22 07:32:38

Where the heck is Omar? Is he hiding under his desk or something?

I don’t want an attention wh*re like Philips as GM, but is it me or has this guy become invisible?

And I definitely feel like this team is waiting for the “other shoe to drop” like HR said last night, you can almost reach out and touch it.

They are going to have to move fast and either cut Randolph loose, or let this team know soon that he is not going anywhere until the end of the year.

Someone wake up the GM, please.

Comment by Matthew Cerrone
2008-05-22 07:37:44

I believe he will be on SNY tonight. My guess is the team wanted to let Randolph time for his apology, before Minaya went out and said anything to push the story.

Now, Omar can just cite Willie’s statements and let it be and move on.

Comment by gipper82475
2008-05-22 07:43:59

Matt,

If possible, please post any Minaya interview video (or, if the video is difficult to do, a trascript) for those of us out of towners stuck outside the SNY network range if he appears in studio and stuck with an ATL feed for tonight’s game via Extra Innings even if he appears in the booth.

He has been rather quiet lately.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by gipper82475
2008-05-22 07:56:30

Wow, sorry for the run-on sentence.

 
 
Comment by RPsJacket
2008-05-22 07:47:26

I would imagine Omar and Co. know the clubhouse much better than we do. If Randolph has somehow “lost” the team, they should be the first to know it and that, to me, is the single most important factor in showing him the door. All the comments from the players appear to support him, I have not really heard any “anonymous” quotes or whispers, but who knows.

However, its tough to look at their play in ATL and the timing of Randolph’s comments/firestorm surrounding him and just wonder if they are related, and if keeping Randolph around is actually becoming an additional burden and putting more pressure on a slumping club. Or it could just be Turner Field, we have seen it before.

In any case, they do need to move past this, one way or another. I will be interested in hearing from Omar on the state of the team.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
 
Comment by Horseman
2008-05-22 08:00:47

Omar has disappeared just like Delgado after games. Shocker.

Comment by cyclone
2008-05-22 13:27:36

Billy Wagner is on Metsblog!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
 
 
Comment by gipper82475
2008-05-22 07:40:03

Willie says he thought the Ian O’Connor conversation was off-the-record. Everybody knows that off-the-record discussions are used for players, manager, politicians, etc to get the truth or what they think is the truth out to reporters without it being quoted.

The subsequent apologies, mea culpas, etc are just spin and damage control.

If he thought the O’Connor interview was off-the-record, then what Willie expressed in that interview (the race card, the “hiding” mets fans, and his paranoid delusions about SNY) are his true thoughts.

It is time to end this nightmare. It is time for Mr. Randolph to go.

Comment by RPsJacket
2008-05-22 07:51:54

I am one of those who believes his comments weren’t all that bad, and were way too over-analyzed. If they were said in the off-season, it would hardly be a story.

However, the reaction is what it is, and has been very detrimental I think. Also, the fact that he gave this ridiculous interview, at the worst possible time, is a head-scratcher for sure.

Comment by gipper82475
2008-05-22 07:55:06

RPsJacket,

We’ll have to agree to disagree as far as your first paragraph.

Your second paragraph is spot-on, though.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by RPsJacket
2008-05-22 08:00:42

Yes, and it almost doesn’t matter what anyone thinks he meant or didn’t mean, the reaction and any impact on his struggling club is the only reality that matters.

Horrible judgement on his part, perhaps his biggest blunder to date.

 
 
 
Comment by Reyesing Shea
2008-05-22 07:52:08

I want him to go also but did feel a little compassion for him while he spoke…i just wish there was a really good person to replace him…freakin alou is too much…i wonder what it is going to take for mr randolph to be gone…if they lose the next 4 on this trip will that do it,,,just johann losing today should be enough…i want the mets to win but i want willie gone…i may need to go back into therapy duet this….i never thought i had MPD til now…

Comment by RPsJacket
2008-05-22 07:57:42

I don’t hate him at all. I think he is a good man, and I bet his players do too.

If they lose today, and sweep Colorado, they have a 5-4 trip. And its not like Turner Field has ever been friendly to ANY Mtes team.

I know, I sound delusional, but it could happen….coffee’s brewing…

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Nate W.
2008-05-22 08:46:53

I can see Santana winning today. The Braves are so lefty heavy that he can handle them single handedly and take the game to Wagner, or maybe Sanchez for an out or two.

if they win just 1 in Colorado, and do the same against the Marlins and Dodgers they will be close to 5 under .500 and the other shoe will have to drop.

 
 
 
 
Comment by The Ghost of Shea Past
2008-05-22 07:47:51

This is turning into a circus.

Comment by gipper82475
2008-05-22 07:52:21

It’s been a circus filled with tragic clowns since 07.

 
 
Comment by darrendaye
2008-05-22 07:50:36

For me personally, I was instantly against hiring Willie Randolph. When word came out of his poor interviews at the time the job went to Art Howe, I thought that should have closed the door to his candidacy. On top of that, the thought that Willie interviewed poorly (reportedly unprepared) as a result of his believing the interview was a charade and that the job was already Howe’s actually cemented my resolve rather than softened it. To me, that was a good sign of how he responded to adversity and it would not have spoke well of his leadership temperment to fold in the tent, so to speak.

 
Comment by backinbusiness
2008-05-22 08:07:45

Both Eddie C last night and Adam Rubin today report that Willie said he reached out to the Wilpons to apologize directly before the media apology but he could not reach them.

Isn’t this startlingly bad, or at least telling?

Comment by RPsJacket
2008-05-22 08:16:33

Good question, either way its bad. If a manager can’t reach ownership or they don’t immediately get to him if they know he wants to talk to him, thats just sad. If they are playing mind games with him, that is sad as well.

Just do something, or let him know he’s staying. How do you not take calls from your manager?

The Wilpons never needed any additional ammunition to fire Randolph, they have had all they needed. They could have done it at any time prior to these comments, and they still can. They should let him and the team know where he stands.

Comment by gipper82475
2008-05-22 08:21:06

They may just be waiting til he returns from the road trip to, er, sit down with him and do the deed. Or, they may be trying to hold to their previous commitment to wait until the end of May to assess the situation.

But the message does seem to be that they are letting him twist in the wind. As Howie said last night, this is a team waiting for the other shoe to drop.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
 
 
Comment by Horseman
2008-05-22 08:15:16

The mets should bring in Barry Bonds and Pete Rose to complete this circus.

 
Comment by Nate W.
2008-05-22 08:43:51

I’m more positive now, positive that his tenure as manager will be ending soon.

 
Comment by dap260
2008-05-22 08:51:31

75% of the respondents have a negative view.

Willie is not a bad person, he is a bad manager.

For heaven’s sake cut the guy loose and let’s get on with then ext chapter.

 
Comment by Thee Bruce Dickenson
2008-05-22 09:01:29

Willie apologized….. time to move on from this subject.

Comment by gipper82475
2008-05-22 09:16:21

It is time to move on…Willie must do so. Move on, Wille. Get going. See ya! Ciao! Smell you later!

 
 
Comment by Metlomaniac
2008-05-22 09:05:11

I’m probably in the minority here, but as an early Willie critic, I thought he did OK on FAN yesterday. He should have said that from the beginning, “Look, I was frustrated and said some things I shouldn’t have”. Also a hattip to Fatso and Fruitloops, as they did not duck tough questions,, but were generally fair and supportive.

I think it is well past time to move past the “racist” comments, but we need to address the product on the field. It stinks. This team has no life, and once they get down, as Mike Nichols said, you know it’s over. That is not a good sign for a manager. Even after last night’s debacle, Willie came out with that monotone, “We have to play better”, “the guys are working hard”, etc. I’ll give him credit for pointing out Castillo’s horrid AB, but the message he is sending the team is it’s business as usual, keep working hard and everything will be fine.

But everything is not fine. This team has no life. As I’ve said many times, a lot of this is Omar’s doing; he has stocked the roster with low-key, quiet guys. If you’re going to do that, you need a more charismatic manager to take the press heat off the players, and to motivate them when they are down, and rip them when they are playing poorly.