Matthew Cerrone

Poll: If Wagner is Out for Year, Who is Closer
By Matthew Cerrone - Sep 8, 2008 10:40 am

Billy Wagner tried to pitch a simulated game yesterday afternoon, but could only make it through one batter before being shut down after feeling pain in his elbow when throwing his slider.

According to ESPN’s Jon Miller, during last night’s broadcast, Wagner was in tears following his failed effort.

Though Mets GM Omar Minaya would not categorize it as a ‘setback,’ he told reporters that Wagner will visit a doctor today to determine how best to proceed.

In Newsday, David Lennon provides more detail, and writes, “It appears that Wagner’s comeback attempt is likely over.”

However, Wagner later told the New York Post that he hasn’t ‘written off this season.’

Nevertheless, since being acquired from the Nationals, Luis Ayala is 5 for 6 in save opportunities with a 2.70 ERA in 10 appearances for the Mets.

Ayala, as quoted by Bart Hubbuch in the Post, said:

“I feel bad for Billy, but I’m here for whatever the team needs and I know I can do the job.”

By the way, as a whole, the Mets bullpen has not allowed a run during their last seven appearances – spanning 26.2 innings.

If Wagner remains on the disabled list, who do you trust most to be the team’s closer?


View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

122 Responses to “Poll: If Wagner is Out for Year, Who is Closer”

  1. Jaded1983 says:

    I dont know about the rest of you guys, but I feel confident when I see Ayala getting up for the 9th. True he is no Mariano, but he is aggressive, throws strikes, has good movement, and is not afraid to come inside on hitters.

    id rather have a guy come straight at someone rather than “nibble” around the corners and Ayala seems to do a great job of that. it helps that he typically has good D behind him as well. but as long as he can keep throwing strikes, im all for ayala.

    • Chan Ho Parking Lot says:

      Yes, I agree. Throughout his career, he has very low walk totals. So far with the Mets, in 10 innings pitched, he only has 1. Walks will kill you every time, especially in save situations.

  2. Flushing_is_Burning says:

    Stokes is the go-to set-up man, Ayala is the closer. And if he needs rest, maybe Joe Smith

  3. JamesK says:

    Correct me if I’m wrong, but didn’t Ayala give up a run on a sac fly in the 9th inning last night?

    Maybe you mean the pen hasn’t given up an earned run over that span?

  4. starz31 says:

    No matter who is closing…I will be a nervous-wreck every time.

  5. Dirtysanchez says:

    Ayala should be anointed with the closer role period. We have played closer by commitee for too long now and i would rather manuel just try to set some sort of roles in the bullpen. Great pickup by omar as im sure the omar bashers will find fault.

    • Ceetar says:

      “i would rather manuel just try to set some sort of roles in the bullpen”

      I thought he did that when he took over? Oh right..all talk and nothing to back it up.

      It’d be nice to give some of these guys some chances, so we could know who is capable of coming through in a big Inning, not just a big spot.

      • ravi3 says:

        Its hard to establish roles when all of your guys are set-up men

      • metsrbest says:

        Manuel gave both Heilman and Sanchez a chance to define there roles. Each of them failed. Ayala and Stokes have stepped up. It’s crystal clear to me that both Heilman and Schoenweis are on the mop up team. The roles look to me pretty defined now…. 7th inning Feliciano/Smith/Sanchez….8th inning Stokes….9th inning Ayala. If anyone ever told me at the beginning of the season that we would have someone closing who was taken off the Washington Nationals scrap heap, AND successful at it, I would have thought they were nuts. Sometimes you just never know.

      • Dirtysanchez says:

        We have been experimenting with the main relief corpse and ayala seems to be the one who performed the best in save situations. The race is too tight imo to experiment with closer by committee again. Imo, let ayala close and match up relief based on the hitter to get to ayala.

        • Ceetar says:

          Look, I know Manuel’s mostly managed as if he has nothing to lose, but he has to think about the Playoffs too. and he won’t have 97 people to mix and match for 2-4 innings during the postseason.

  6. zen says:

    hopefully nest year it will be f-rod.

    surely it will be ayala for the near future though heilman has the stuff to be closer. i really hope he can be the one as i’d prefer him in his best form. usually he’s much better in the second half

  7. mikey_FF says:

    I have not missed Wagner … and I won’t.

    • Gland says:

      I’m not really sure why this is a poll. It’s pretty obvious that Manuel has already made Ayala the closer.

    • LongJohnMaine says:

      Hear hear. I feel bad for the guy that he’s hurt, but the numbers speak for themselves. 22-11 w/o him. Say it with me everyone: “Big money closers not named Mariano are overrated.”

      • Ceetar says:

        You’re drunk if you think Wagner back wouldn’t be a huge plus.

        Unless you’re saying Wagner was the problem not Willie.

        • mikey_FF says:

          No, it’s just that he’s a loser at heart. Mets will never win the big game with Billy on the mound in a crucial spot.

        • LongJohnMaine says:

          I hated Willie. Obviously it’s not Willie’s fault Wagner decided to have the worst run of his career in his last week as manager of this team, but that’s history.

          Wagner has blown about 20 saves in a little over two and a half years as a Met. For someone who is supposed to be an elite closer, that frigging sucks, there’s no way around it. He had what, 7 this year alone in 4 months? Not to mention the couple of games this season he came within inches of blowing.

        • Ceetar says:

          HAHAHAHAH…he’s a loser at heart.

          That’s funny. It means nothing. Might as well give us the title now, because I’d say Rollins and Howard are both losers at hearts too. In fact, the whole 10k thing pretty much says the entire Phillies franchise are losers.

          Wagner over whoever would get the bump (which would actually be a problem now..I don’t think you bump Aaron, Feliciano, Smith, Schoeneweis..and you can’t do Stokes or Ayala the way they’ve been pitching..)

        • mikey_FF says:

          Wagner’s freakin elbow is about to FALL OFF!!! He’s not that good when he’s HEALTHY!!!!

          WAKE UP!!!!

        • metsftw says:

          he’s not good? how is he not good? because you only remember the saves that he’s blown? pathetic.

        • mikey_FF says:

          He’s not THAT good. The word “THAT” is an important word in the sentence.

          It implies, he’s not great yet he’s not bad. He’s not THAT good.

          THAT is the truth.