Buzz: Marlins Willing to Trade Johnson…or Not

November 28, 2009 at 10:09 am · 6 comments

by Michael Baron

John Perrotto of Baseball Prospectus says the Marlins are willing to deal Josh Johnson now for the right package.

However, Joe Frisaro of MLB.com says not to buy into such speculation and Buster Olney of ESPN says according to rival executives, the Marlins have not indicated that Johnson is available yet.

…i think the Mets will be keeping a close eye on this situation, and i also think this would be the better option to Roy Halladay considering his age and the long term outlook that Johnson would give the Mets…i do think the cost could be higher considering Florida has control of the Marlins for two more years, so they can afford to be patient and wait for the right deal…

unless Florida is blown away with an offer this winter, i don’t see them trading their ace away, considering they are likely to contend with the Phillies in 2010…

Last week, Jerry Crasnick of ESPN said Johnson and the Marlins have reached an impasse on a long term contract, which you can read here.

{ 6 comments }

brye65 November 28, 2009 at 10:23 am

I think Johnson would be better long term for the Mets than Halladay but would the Marlins trade within the NL East ? I don’t think the Marlins will talk to a division rival. One thing that would benefit the Mets is taking on salary from the Marlins. I would offer F-Mart, Meija, Tejada to start.

MetsFan06 November 28, 2009 at 10:40 am

I totally agree. I think he is a very good pitcher but the Marlins would have even more pitching difficulties if they traded him.

BBmetsfreak36 November 28, 2009 at 11:23 am

I believe if your going to make a big trade with big time prospects, it should be for this guy. He’s the kind of big tall hard throwing pitchers we would see 15 years ago. Normally you hesitate to trade the future for an ageing superstar, but the way I look at it is tradeing away a few of your maybe maybe’s and in return getting a good #2 pitcher for the future. These are the kind of long term core players the mets need to build around. Reyes,Wright, Frenchy,Beltran and another premier star. Along with 2 starters like Santana and Johnson. With a bulpen core of K-rod maybe a new set-up guys,Feliciano and Parnell. Once you have the framework of a winning team, filling holes as Omar does remarkably well, is a much easier task.
This is why I believe the mets should go big after a not only win-now player, but as well as 5 years down the road. A core like that is worth giving up a few maybe prospects like F-Mart, Meija or Tehada. A long as its not Ike Davis.

FelixMillan November 28, 2009 at 1:05 pm

Everything. Plus the kitchen sink. Johnson has only scratched at the surface of how dominating he can be.

astromets November 28, 2009 at 1:51 pm

Right but Johnson has been injured in multiple seasons, so that makes me a little nervous. Plus, with him under their control for a couple more years they are going to ask for the whole farm; I guess they would ask to start with F-Mart, Mejia, Tejada, Davis, Flores and Holt/Niese. Remember, this is the same team that was not willing to budge off of a Wright for Willis trade a few years back, and that was when Willis was in decline whereas Johnson seems more of a certainty.

brye65 November 28, 2009 at 7:09 pm

Marlins are not in a hurry to trade Johnson. They have control over him for 2 years. Marlins will hold out for the best offer and no doubt will want Ike Davis from us. I like Johnson better but it comes down to this. The availability right now. Halliday or Lackey?

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: