In mid-January, I was able to talk with Daniel Murphy about a variety of issues.
Here is an excerpt, in which we talk about hitting, and what he learned from last season:
Matthew Cerrone: I don’t know if you listen to talk radio in New York ever, but, Mike Francesa on WFAN has been very critical of you, and he even addressed this with Omar Minaya and Jeff Wilpon at the end of last season, when he basically said, “Well, you can’t win a championship if you don’t have a power-hitting first baseman,” essentially saying, “You need to get homeruns from first base.” I am curious, what do you think about that?
Daniel Murphy: I think you need someone out there that’s going to have quality at bats. I think that if I am able to go out there… I never want to try to put numbers on anything because that’s so unattainable, because you can’t control RBI’s, you can’t control hits, because you can hit the ball hard five times a day, every day for the entire season and not get one… But, if I go out there and I have a good at bat, and mostly have good at bats with runners in scoring position, then for us, if I look up and I’m .290 with 15 to 20 home runs with 90 RBI, but I helped this club win a Championship, great, and that’s the way I look at it.
Matthew Cerrone: Well, if you guys win, and you put up those numbers, like you said, say, .290 and 20 HR, people would be thrilled and you’d be quite popular around here… I know you love hitting. What is the biggest adjustment you had to make from last season? I know mid-season there had to be a moment where it was like, ‘What is going on here?” What’s the biggest thing you had to tackle?
Daniel Murphy: My biggest struggle was from May to June; I just didn’t swing the bat very well. It was a combination of the pitchers adjusting to me and a little bit of my own stubbornness and saying that I am still going to do what I want. I’d say, ‘I’m still going to take this ball and hit it up the middle or the other way.’ But, once I sat down and talked to HoJo, I realized that if the pitchers are going to make this adjustment to me, I’ve now got to now make an adjustment to them.
Matthew Cerrone: I talked to David Wright years ago, when he went through his first year and that was his big thing, he called it a cat and mouse game. Saying, it’s a constant back and forth, the pitchers are doing this, so you’re going to do that, then they adjust, and you adjust back, and so on, and it’s back and forth. It seems like that never ends, right?
Daniel Murphy: Something David does so well, which I struggled with last year, is how quickly he can make an adjustment. My first adjustment in the big leagues took six weeks, maybe two months… I think that learning curve and that process is going to be a little bit shorter for me now. It shouldn’t take that long this year, it shouldn’t take me two months to make an adjustment to what they are doing to me out there.
Matthew Cerrone: Is that a byproduct of working with HoJo, or guys that you work with? Can you rush that adjustment time, or does that have to come on your own terms?
Daniel Murphy: I think the learning experience comes with you. But you also have so many assets to use. I mean, David has hit 30 home runs and hit .300 every year since he got to the big leagues, pretty much… He has hit and continues to hit, so obviously he has something figured out that he is doing right. It’s my job to get that out of him. It’s not the exact way I’m going to go about my business, because we are two different people, but he has something figured out and I will continue to talk to him as much as I can. The nature of the beast is that you are going to struggle, you play 162 ball games and you aren’t going to feel good every day. The thing he does is how short can you make that struggle? Is it a week? Is it a month? Is it a day? Is it a swing? My job is to make it one at bat, that’s how long the struggle should be.
Matthew Cerrone: One of the things that Keith Hernandez talked about was how a batter should never waste his best in the batting cage. He says there are only so many hits in a hitting streak, so don’t waste them in the cage. If you are hot, save it for the game. Then, if you are struggling, you will hit your way out of it. Take as many swings as you can. Does that make sense to you? Do you look at it that way?
Daniel Murphy: I am a cerebral hitter. I’m always thinking about how I can get better, and sometimes I mess with my swing… I was locked in during spring training, I felt prepared and I felt ready for the season. But, I messed with it just enough to screw it up… Now I understand, there is a difference between working and working smart. That is one thing I have taken from this past season, you know, I don’t have to take 150 swings in spring training on day one to be ready for the season. If I feel right, or I feel good after 15 or 20 swings, then I feel good… It’s a learning process to understand that… if I feel right, I’m going to leave it alone.
Matthew Cerrone: Sure, because I would think, if you’re clicking and taking extra BP, then you do something wrong for just one swing, you might start second guessing yourself, and then there it goes… is that what you mean?
Daniel Murphy: Right. One of the jobs you have as a hitter is you’re not always going to feel great in there. But you have to prepare yourself and just go to battle that night. I’ve got to get myself into a position where I can help this team win tonight. I feel like crap, but I’ve got to do something tonight, I’ve got to scratch out a walk, move a runner over, and hit a sack fly or whatever it takes to do something positive tonight. If you look at it that way then it’s not that I don’t feel good, it’s what am I supposed to do for the rest of the week or the month? It’s: let’s take care of tonight. It can be as simple as a foul ball that has locked me back in and that’s all it takes.
Thank you to SMG Transcription for transcribing this interview.




I’m hoping forthe best, Daniel. Do Work!
Good or Bad, Murphys our first baseman this year. I hope he matures into the hitter the Mets thought he would be. It would be a nice success story if he could turn into a decent hitter…290, 20 hr, 90 rbi…eventually.
I would be thrilled with .290, 20 dingers and 90 ribbies. I know those numbers aren’t wrecking machine-like power, but chicks can dig the long ball, 20 homers is fine by me. :)
Agreed, those numbers coupled with improved defense at 1st would go a long way to the Mets having a successful season.
Once again Mike Francesca sounds like an moron when he says things like:
“Well, you can’t win a championship if you don’t have a power-hitting first baseman,” essentially saying, “You need to get homeruns from first base.”
It’s happen plenty of times over the history of baseball that championship teams don’t need a Homer Run hitter at 1st base to win a championship.
i bet most of those teams got production out of C or 2B
and the Mets will get above AVG power from CF and SS.
Oh, and 2B isn’t a typical power position and we’ve got OBP there.
and C..well, lots of teams have crappy catchers.
you have to shoot yourself to try and play logic with some people. If you are getting above avg performance from a different postion then you can take a less than avg at another position. The idea that you have to have a power hitting 1B at first when, in theory we will have around 70+ HRs from all our outfielders. factor in SS and..
Ceetar, why am I bothering?
I keep telling myself to stop reading/writing comments here, but I don’t.
I’m with you… I tell myself the same thing every day and yet i’m on here reading them and commenting.
I’m excited for this season to begin. So everyone can stop speculating and just talk about the on field production.
Murphy does have some potential. Whether or not he develops into a decent hitter remains to be seen, but Francesa makes it like he will hit .220 with 3 hr and 19 rbi.
Sometimes I think Francesa is just jealous of ballplayers. From the looks of him, he was probably the kid picked last for every pick up game. Although he was probably useful in playing “around the world’ if you actually used him as the “world.”
he’s jealous of all ball players who aren’t in pinstripes. If you wear pinstripes he’s IN LOVE with you
Murphy: 95 OPS+
average 1B NL: 130 OPS+
Reyes 2008: 118 OPS+
average SS NL: 100 OPS+
Wright average of (2008 + 2009):132
average 3B NL: 113 OPS+
Murphy + Reyes + Wright = 95 + 118 + 132 = 345
Average 1B + SS + 3B = 130 + 100 + 113 = 343
Basically Murphy negates Reyes and Wright. So now you have washes at 1B, 2B (believe it or not), SS, and 3B,
2004-Kevin Millar
2002-Scott Spiezio
2001-Mark Grace
2000-Tino Martinez
Etc, etc.
Ok, you’ve proved my point. You found 4 examples of light hitting 1B out of 30 playoff team years. That is less than a 10% success rate.
But let’s explore your implication one by one:
They had Varitek at 121 OPS +; Ortiz at 145 OPS+, and Manny at 152 OPS+. They also had a total of 7 starters with an OPS+ over 100.
They had Schilling at 150; Pedro at 125 and Arroyo at 121 ERA+
Their bullpen had a 182 ERA+
The Mets are nowhere near those levels, even if you use 2008 data for the injured players.
And Millar had an OPS+ or 117 (117% – 95% = 22% better than Murphy.
So Millar is not a true counter example.
Spiezio : OPS+ of 115. 7 of 9 starters had an OPS+ over 100 and they had a team ERA+ of 120. So Spiezio is not a true counter example
Grace OPS+ of 113
that was the year Schilling had an ERA+ of 157 and Johnson’s was 187. Nobody in their bullpen had an ERA+ less than 95 and Gonzo had an OPS+ of 174
Again, not a true counter example
Tino. OPS+ of 89. You found 1. You have made my point. Thank you.
I really like murphy, and if last years UZR numbers are indicative of his defensive skill at 1B, 20 HR and 90 RBI is going to be solid production from him. Especially if his OBP is 350+ in the 6 or 7 hole that is excellent.
I think its tough for murphy though when he has to compare with the current crop of NL 1B, offensively he does not really match up with any of these guys:
Pujols, Howard, Fielder, Gonzo, Reynolds, Berkman, Votto, Sandoval, Derek Lee, Cantu, Helton. Thats 11 out of 16 NL teams, and I don’t think anyone in their right mind can expect murphy to outperform any of those 11 guys offensively. So the best we can hope for is something like the 12th best 1B in the NL, hopefully he can outperform guys like Loney and Laroche.
Yes, for 1B murphy seems subpar. However considering we have tremendous production from 2 positions where teams rarely get production from (3B and CF), we can live with murphy posting 290/350/15 hr/90 rbi type numbers with solid defense.
you have pretty high hopes for pagan and GMJ
2 months of Pagan + rest of the season of Beltran will still crush almost every other teams production from CF.
especially if it’s only one month of Pagan.
Also, Pagan offensively is probably better than most NL starting Centerfielders. Only guys I would have over pagan are Kemp, Victorino, Mclouth, and Beltran. Maybe Nyjer Morgan but that depends on if you prefer some extra pop or some extra base hits. Pagan has more pop, morgan gets more hits.
I see your point about “12th best 1B”, but perhaps a better comp would be how he fits into the lineup. With a healthy Beltran, Murphy would be expected to be, at best, the team’s 5th or 6th most productive hitter (behind Beltran, Wright, Reyes, and Bay, and perhaps Francoeur). So instead of measuring him against Pujols and Howard, you’d be measuring him against guys like Skip Schumaker, Julio Lugo, Shane Victorino, and Jayson Werth, which gives him at least a shot at success.
Very nice interview Matthew. You are good at asking tough questions yet bringing out certain aspects of their personality. It’s easy to forget that these pro players are human beings with dreams, fears and challenges rather than cold hearted road warriors.
I agree, excellent interview. I also loved Murphy’s responses, he sounds like he understands exactly what he has to do and how to approach things. If he’s healthy, his numbers should increase across the board. We’ll see just how much.
Murphy is a smart guy and runs on a Calvinist work ethic, and I’m optimistic that he’s going to use those characteristics to become a more dangerous presence in the batter’s box.
i find this to be poor logic. just cuz we are blessed to have production from spots where teams don’t typically get production does not mean we should accept a lack of production from a position where everyone else gets it. your making excuses why its ok to be average when they are missing a very easy to acquire piece that would make them superiour. other teams have the excuse that it is difficult to find hitters like beltran and reyes for SS and CF. the Mets have no excuse, as good hitting 1b are a dime a dozen. if you put even an average, cheap, easy to acquire player like LaRoche at 1st it would have improved the Mets offense more than any other move they could have made this off season, even the oft spoken of Castillo for Hudson switch.
Actually Murphy isn’t even close to average. See above
i know he’s a small, well spoken irish white guy, the kind we all love to root for, but i cannot stand these daniel murphy apologists. he’s like wayne chrebet with even LESS production.
I don’t think .290, 20 hr, 90 RBI, with 40 doubles is out of the picture… But, I could live with .275, 15 hr, and 75 RBI especially when beltran comes back. I think Murphy has upside, and his defense at 1B was ok last year, and with working with Keith it will just get better. He is going to be fine as our starting 1B, the guy works hard, studies the game, and is a gritty player…..guys like him and F-Core add that character and backbone the Mets need game in and game out.
He single handedly negates the contributions of Wright and Reyes.
UZR, as a measure, for 1B is not the best and unreliable in general for partial seasons. The statistical support for his fielding ability is dubious at best.
From what I remember about Keith a lot of his greatness came from reaction times that were other worldly. There are parts of the game he can teach Murphy; but he will never be close to Keith on reactions – nobody has.
I know he is what we have, and honestly I wish for the best, but the reality isn’t pretty.
It’s true he is not the best but last year he was a rookie who had to learn 2 new positions on the fly, and he never had a full season of AAA, and was forced to bat all over the Met lineup with very little protection… I don’t think we can rule out improvement in both defense and hitting… Now I don’t have statistics to back up the feeling that I have that he will improve, but there is no statistics saying he can’t either
Overall, I am also hoping for the best, but with this team…I think that’s all we can do now
I agree with Sylow on his point about Murphy negating Wright/Reyes, but I have to admit, after reading the transcript, it is very hard not to root for a guy like this. I do think that if he puts up numbers even close to what is mentioned in the article, he will have turned out to be the best option. In addition, there is also something to be said for character, and he seems to have it. He went through a tough year last year, didn’t make excuses and went back to work. Maybe if the team starts to develop similar attitude (Ollie? are you listening) it can make up for a lack of natural gifts.
He is being compared to Keith Hernandez, which isn’t fair to Hernandez or Murphy because he plays the same position. Perhaps a better comparison would be Ray Knight from the same team. I didn’t hear too many complaints about his lack of natural ability.
I don’t dislike him and I hope be pans out. My point is that he is a drain on the offense.
when do you sleep?
Central time zone
Great questions, Matt. And yes, both Daniel and D-Wright tend to be cerebral and let their heads mess with their comfort at the plate. Hopefully Murphy has learned how to temper his overthinking–it sounds like he’s worked on it. Reading stuff like this makes me excited to see our boys in action.
I think Murphy will have a breakout year this year,but I think Hank Blayock is still available,and would be a good fit coming off the bench.granted he’s not a great fielder,but he could be a good insurance policy at 1st and 3rd.