MetsBlog Link

Decisions on Pelfrey, Acosta & Paulino will be tonight

posted on December 12th, 2011 at 8:19 am

Tonight is the deadline for teams to decide whether to cut or keep arbitration-eligible players for next season. If the player is non-tendered, he becomes a free agent. If he is tendered a deal, it is essentially a guaranteed one-year contract. However, if he and the team cannot reach agreement on a salary, the player can choose to have that number determined by an arbitrator.

Ronny Paulino, Mike Pelfrey and Manny Acosta are all eligible for arbitration.


Matthew Cerrone: There might be talk of non-tendering Pelfrey, but I’m sure he’ll be offered a contract. Yes, he can be frustrating to watch. However, the team and league values innings pitched and, at the very least, he delivers them and with potential. I bet he earns around $6 million next season, which is about right considering what comparable pitchers are getting on the open market and since he’s worth twice that in his best season (2010), and half that in his worst season (2011).

I had been expecting the team to offer arbitration to Acotsa, who, for an estimated $1 million, would worth keeping. But, I wonder if acquiring Ramon Ramirez and Jon Rauch last week will have an impact on how the team looks at Manny and his salary today?

Paulino will likely earn around $1.5 million. However, though that is probably market value for his performance, the buzz around the team indicates there are concerns about his lack of preparation and way about the clubhouse. Also worth noting, as Adam Rubin writes for ESPN, “If Paulino remains, the Mets will need to make a different 40-man roster move in order to have room to add free-agent relievers Frank Francisco and Jon Rauch, whose signings have yet to be officially announced.” I stil think he gets cut loose, since there are so many other alternatives on the free-agent market (all likely to earn around the same money).


According to this post on MLB Trade Rumors, LHP Tom Gorzelanny, LHP Joe Saunders, IF Ryan Theriot, and C Jesus Flores are all candidates to be non-tendered tonight.